PORTLAND, Maine — Madeleine Albright told Portland audience members on Saturday afternoon they must be willing to listen to political opinions that challenge theirs.
Albright, a prominent Democrat who was the first woman to become U.S. Secretary of State in 1997, said her mentor, the late former U.S. Sen. Edmund Muskie of Maine, was willing to buck his own party in the name of what was best for America.
“Even though he was a loyal Democrat, he infuriated many when he said, ‘What’s so damn liberal about wasting money?’” Albright told a packed Hannaford Hall on the University of Southern Maine’s Portland campus. “Voters and nonvoters sent their leaders a message on Election Day that they want them to stop bickering and get something done. Whether you blame Democrats or Republicans for the political gridlock, there’s no denying it hurts our country and our standing abroad.”
Albright was joined at the event by fellow speaker Mark Shields, a longtime syndicated political columnist and analyst on the PBS program “NewsHour.”
The talk was held as part of a series of activities celebrating the 100th anniversary of the birth of Muskie, an influential lawmaker behind the federal Clean Air and Clean Water acts in the early 1970s and is the namesake behind University of Southern Maine’s public policy school.
Muskie also spent four years as Maine’s governor in the late 1950s and served nine months as U.S. secretary of state under President Jimmy Carter from 1980 to 1981. He was the 1968 Democratic vice presidential nominee and was also a candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination in 1972.
“Ed Muskie never would have approved of the politics of today, where 90 percent of the political ads on television are meant to savage the other guy,” Shields said. “That wasn’t the politics of Edmund Muskie.”
Both Albright and Shields lamented the explosion of large donations in political campaigns in recent years, spurred in part by the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2010 ruling that donors’ use of money is constitutionally protected as free expression and could not be limited.
“If you’re running for president, you’re going to spend time with people with money — big money,” Shields said. “These aren’t people who go to public schools or depend on public transportation or public recreation or public places.
“I hope we have a scandal of dramatic proportions in 2016 that shakes people up and says, ‘My God, we can’t do this, we can’t have our government bought and sold by big money,’” he continued. “It’s going to take a cellphone
of somebody saying to a candidate, ‘We gave you $200,000, and you bet your bippy you’re going to vote this way.’”
Albright said Americans can begin to reverse the tide of hyper-partisanship plaguing politics today by keeping open minds and listening to people whose opinions differ from their own. She said she listens to conservative talk show host Rush Limbaugh on the radio regularly.
Albright said conservatives should be open to the idea that government programs are sometimes needed and positive, and liberals should be open to the idea that the government can be too big and wasteful.
“The men and women who founded our country loved freedom, but their goal was not to eliminate government. For all of its shortcomings, our government should be a source of pride for our citizens,” she said.
“Taxes are not a crime,” Albright continued. “Taxes are how we pay for the things we all share, but people need to know that even some of us who do support good government think it’s gotten a little out of control.”
The former secretary of state said, “One of the qualities Senator Muskie had was he listened.”
“Not only do you have to listen, but you have to listen to diverse ideas,” she said. “One thing that worries me, along with [the influence of] money, is people are only tuning in to whatever they already believe in. … There is an enormous difference between entering into an argument for the purpose of winning and entering into a dialogue for better understanding.”
Albright’s talk in Portland came less than two weeks after Election Day, when Republicans claimed sweeping victories both nationally and locally, taking control of both the Maine and U.S. Senate, and increasing their numbers in the GOP-held U.S. House and Democrat-led state House.
Incumbent Republican Maine Gov. Paul LePage, who many political analysts considered vulnerable, also decisively turned away a challenge from popular six-term U.S. Rep. Mike Michaud, D-Maine.
Shields and Albright said Democrats and Republicans alike must be open to re-evaluating their positions and finding common ground.
“As Madeleine said, Ed Muskie asked the question many of us liberals don’t want to confront, which is ‘What is so liberal about spending a lot of money?’” Shields said. “We find ourselves defending every government action.”